CG
Collective GENIUS

Comparative Scorecard Matrix

COMPARATIVE SCORECARD MATRIX

CategoryWeightArthur Greenstein CallMike Tedesco CallCommentary
Rapport & Credibility20%
4 – Proficient
Established trust and showed strong industry knowledge; prospect eventually opened up about challenges.
4 – Proficient
Built rapport quickly; industry credibility clear.
Rapport is consistently a strength; Leon connects easily and sounds credible.
Framing & Structure15%
1 – Needs Major Improvement
Intro lasted until 2:30; prospect explicitly said "I still don't understand." Visuals/qualifiers arrived too late.
2 – Emerging
Framing too slow; visuals shared at 22:43.
Biggest consistent weakness; Leon must deliver a clear 60-sec intro with visuals/qualifiers up front.
Objection Handling15%
2 – Emerging
Did not capitalize when prospect admitted "outgrown coaching." Defaulted to general talk.
2 – Emerging
Created needless objections around time; accepted "Shoot me an email."
Leon introduces or accepts objections instead of reframing them into closes.
Closing Sequence Discipline25%
2 – Emerging
Prospect gave a hard "Yes" for March but Leon deferred to email instead of securing deposit.
2 – Emerging
Prospect asked for the close, but Leon pivoted to small talk and avoided deposit ask.
Critical failure point in both calls: Leon doesn't convert "Yes" moments into card-in-hand closes.
Tone & Confidence15%
2 – Emerging
Apologetic when discussing time; lacked authority.
2 – Emerging
Closing tone sheepish, tentative.
Both calls show apologetic tone that undermines persuasion.
Urgency & Persuasion10%
1 – Needs Major Improvement
Allowed event logistics to dictate flow; no urgency.
1 – Needs Major Improvement
Accepted deferment; no push for same-call commitment.
Urgency is absent — Leon relies on prospect's timeline rather than creating action.

Weighted Totals

2.15 / 5.0
Arthur Greenstein Call
2.30 / 5.0
Mike Tedesco Call

Observed Patterns

• Strengths:Rapport and credibility — consistently strong.
• Critical Gaps:Framing, Closing Discipline, and Urgency. Both calls show Leon cannot yet turn prospect "Yes" signals into actual commitments.
• Root Issue:Leon defaults to politeness and deference when persuasion and authority are required.
✅ Key Insight

This matrix makes it clear: Leon is stuck at Emerging in closing behaviors, which is where the revenue leakage occurs.